Judy exited the stall and beheld a terrified woman in her 30’s hunched over the sink. She tried to console her and asked what the girl’s name was. She told her that her name was Amy and that she was originally from Virginia. Before she could get any more info, however, Amy left.

Many of these sightings seem to point to one conclusion: Amy had been kidnapped from the cruise ship and sold as a sex slave in the Caribbean slave trade. In November 2005, Amy’s parents appeared on the Dr. Phil Show. They had recently been anonymously emailed a photograph of a girl that looked very much like Amy…